Search blog.co.uk

Why I don’t donate to Burma?

by ranfuchs @ 11/05/2008 - 10:26:33

cyclone

There is little doubt that the Burma cyclone is a large scale humanitarian disaster, even if not so many British were amongst its victims. We have always been much more affected when learning about individual’s tragedies. But just like many other animals, we don’t seem to have the ability to distinguish when numbers gets too big. Yet, we must never forget that despite this inability a thousand deaths are still one thousand individual tragedies.

I know that if aid will not reach the people in the next few days, the death tool may be ten times as large. Yet I did not yet donate to Burma.

Unlike previous disasters such as India or Indonesia, where I knew that despite the great corruption, at least some of the aid money would reach those in need, I have no such belief that this will happen in Burma.

Most of us in the West tend to superficially believe that life of the citizens is of some concern to the regime. However, in big parts of the world this is not the case. Such regimes see people as the means of making the rulers richer and more powerful, nothing more. They welcome disasters, as weak people are less of a threat, and if money also pours in, what can be better? Two birds with one stone.

I believe that any money donated will not reach those in need, but will only strengthen a regime of horror. So as much as my heart aches, quieting my consciousness by claiming ignorance is not the way to go. It’s our politician and government that must push the Myanmar government to allow aid workers in, and open channels by which emergency supplies will reach those in need. Then I will donate.

Trackback address for this post:

authimage

Comments, Trackbacks: Hide subcomments

jackfrostjackfrost pro
11/05/08 @ 10:45

I agree, my brother has worked abroad for years in very desolate places...they had to buy certain supplies from the local offocials...it made him sick to see that the bags they bought had UN aid markings on them and that there were wharehouses full of stuff...but not for the local starving poor....the only aid we should give is the aid we can take and hand over ourselves...

no-one seems to question the fact that we have been giving africa aid for over 50 years sometimes like live aid huge amounts ...so why has non of it helped...when i was in africa many people said that as long as the west keeps donating to africa...africa would always be starving and in crisis...they said the west should just back out...and yes there would be graet loss of life but out of it would be a africa that would then know how to look after it self..

ranfuchsranfuchs pro
11/05/08 @ 10:51

Less extreme example is the aboriginals in Australia. They have been ‘reconciliation’ money for year. This freed many communities from the need to do any work whatsoever. Although a few communities (those who allowed the traditional ways to continue, and not allowed human right advocates to destroy their life) most have managed to create a well paid unemployed communities – a total disaster.

safrizsafriz [Member]
http://www.conspiror.blog.co.uk
11/05/08 @ 11:55

In many ways i agree with you.Masses are always fooled and bluffed.No matter if its Africa or western Europe.Not every penny of the aid money people will donate from their hard earned cash will reach Burma.Most part of it won't leave Britain in the first place.
This has happened so many times.In oct 2005 there was a big earthquake in Pakistan,and people round the world donated aid money for the country.
Did all of it ever reach Pakistan? the answer is no.Although there was corruption and the relief money and goods that entered the country were misused to some extent.But then so many peole in western europe sincerely gave donations which never could leave their country.

ranfuchsranfuchs pro
11/05/08 @ 11:58

Having lived in Asia for many years, I am well aware of the corruption. However, I would still donate, if I believed that a reasonable amount would reach the victims. This was the case of the tsunami in Indonesia. However, in Burma, I think very little if anything at all will go to anyone who really needs it.

PrettyintelligentprincessPrettyintelligentprincess [Member]
12/05/08 @ 00:16

Yes...I understand how you feel. x

ranfuchsranfuchs pro
12/05/08 @ 08:25

and how do you feel?

PrettyintelligentprincessPrettyintelligentprincess [Member]
17/05/08 @ 16:43

You always try to draw more out of me don't you...I don't want to tell you how I feel right now...but I only need to say that I empathise with what you wrote. That is all. And I'm smiling as I write this...just don't know how to use the smiley thing on comments...

take care x

ranfuchsranfuchs pro
19/05/08 @ 16:13

sure do :)

CassandraofTroyCassandraofTroy [Member]
12/05/08 @ 07:15

There can be a knee-jerk tendency when something awful happens to throw some money at it, and this will make us feel better about ourselves. The aid is desperately needed, and as long as some of it gets through, that is of some benefit.
But often it is done without thinking,and when, at some later date, it is revealed that most if not all of it was siphoned off elsewhere, there is uproar and people want to know why this was not explained to them in the first place. this also has the unfortunate side effect of discrediting organisations which can genuinely help in other circumstances.
it is sad that many well-meaning people don't take the trouble to be informed and think about the background of situations like this.

ranfuchsranfuchs pro
12/05/08 @ 22:07

In Buddhism ignorance is the greatest sin

CassandraofTroyCassandraofTroy [Member]
13/05/08 @ 07:00

Not only in Buddhism.
Wilful ignorance is the worst of all.
But I don't like the word 'sin'. Who are we to judge?

ranfuchsranfuchs pro
13/05/08 @ 08:12

I don't like the word worst, who are we to judge?

CassandraofTroyCassandraofTroy [Member]
13/05/08 @ 08:38

If not us, then who?

ranfuchsranfuchs pro
13/05/08 @ 09:32

US always judges

Melinda_blogMelinda_blog [Member]
13/05/08 @ 09:35

As opposed to WE

Leave a comment :

Your email address will not be displayed on this site.
Your URL will be displayed.
Allowed XHTML tags: <!, p, ul, ol, li, dl, dt, dd, address, blockquote, ins, del, a, span, bdo, br, em, strong, dfn, code, samp, kdb, var, cite, abbr, acronym, q, sub, sup, tt, i, b, big, small, img>
URLs, email, AIM and ICQs will be converted automatically.
Options:
 
(Line breaks become <br />)
(Set cookies for name, email & url)
Validation code:
Please enter the above code here:
For protection from spambots (case-sensitive).