by
ranfuchs
@ 13/12/2007 - 23:23:36
“Sincerity always pays off in the long run” was a statement that unclefrank made in one of our blog discussions a few days ago. (Frank is frank)
I kept thinking about it ever since. How much truth is there in this statement? So let’s imagine a scenario (quite realistic in my opinion) in a relationship in which both partners have agreed to be completely honest with each other.
The man, after a crap day at work, has just arrived back home. The woman sees that he is not well and is trying to find out what went wrong and cheer him up. He, on the other hand, just wants some quiet time, watch TV, or maybe have sex, but definitely he doesn’t want to talk.
W: how was your day, dear?
M: (groans, while turning the TV on): crap.
W: (being sympathetic): Why? What happened?
Now the man has to decide if he is going to be honest, or should he try to keep the peace. He decides to be honest.
M: I don’t feel like talking. Can I just watch football quietly, please? We can talk tomorrow. (nothing rude, just being politely honest)
Now the woman, understandably, feels rejected and hurt. She, as well, can be honest, and express these feelings, or try to keep the peace. Again she goes for honesty.
W: it really irritates me when you just come home, turn on the TV and don’t want to talk. Why don’t you want to talk to me?
The man is facing the same dilemma again, but he still believes that honesty is the best way.
M: Why don’t we just have sex? I really don’t feel like talking now.
You can easily imagine the rest of this evening. So what went wrong? After all both side fulfilled their agreement to be honest.
As long as at least one of the sides is capable of feeling hurt, rejected or insulted a balance between honesty and keeping the peace should be struck. Otherwise, when honesty wins, relationship will lose.
Which is more important? This is a hard question that each of us must answer for themselves.